Detectives serve for a five (5)-year term:

1976 - Amos Kirk & Dr. Cameron Wilson
1977 - Edwin Kemble & Al Becker
1978 - William Lownes & Richard Hoover
1979 - Dave Krewson & J. Hibbs Buckman
1980 - John Benninger & Charles Schwartz
1981 - Ed Swan & Stanley Sutton
1982 - Dr. Thomas Foote & G. Nelson Pfundt
1983 - Bob Knipe & William Dudley
1984 - William Lang & Calvin Terry
1985 - Robert Kenderdine & Ronald Morgan
1986 - Joe Flum & Mike Donovan
1987 - Dr. Fred Guenther & Raymond "Skip" Goodnoe
1988 - Willard Leedom & Winston Ditmars
1989 - Bud Smith & Bill Platt
1990 - Richard Walker & George Stockburger
1991 - Jerry White & Ed Cunfer
1992 - Art Ivins, Jr. & William Gunser
1993 - Wayne Lambert & John Noble
1994 - Joe Valenti & John Weedman
1995 - Paul Lewis & Joe Stone
1996 - Dave Burns & John Newsom
1997 - Jan Gouza & Bob Scheithauer
1998 - Bob Norman & Brian Tomlinson
1999 - John Parry & Blake Parry
2000 - Dirk Dunlap & Craig Burton
2001 - George Dutton & Corky Schwartz
2002 - John Newsome & Dave Burns, Jr.
2003 - Joe Swerk & Dave Burns, Jr.
2004 - Tony Blancato & Bruce Dimicco
2005 - Bill Smith & Brian Rounsavill
2006 - Roy Vanderwyck & Scott Dengler
2007 - Scott Dengler & John Conner
2008 - Tony Blancato & Bruce DiMicco
2009 - Tom Mershon & Mike Miller
2010 - Tom Pizoky & Bill Lucas
2011 - Mike Jenkins & Tony Petsis
2012 - Harold Betts and Roger Cook
2013 - Jeff DeFrehn & Mark Guenther
2014 - Joe Creighton & Rick Rogers
2015 - Bob Musto & Rob Ciervo
2016 - Kyle Dudley & Ryan Perry
2017 - Kevin Bethman & John Horn
2018 - Rick Speranza & Chuck Charlton
2019 - Matt Gillis & Bill Farrell
2020 - Colin Goodnoe & David Millstein
2021 - Chuck Charleton & Rick Speranza
2022 - Kevin Bethman & John Horn
2023 - Kyle Dudley & Ryan Parry
2024 - Jim Baniewicz & Matthew Winslade